New York Bar Tells Lawyers: Bill for Checking AI, Not for the Time It Saved
New ethics guidelines from the New York State Bar Association say hourly billers may charge for prompting and verifying AI, but not for hours the technology saved.
The New York State Bar Association (NYSBA) has adopted detailed ethics guidelines on lawyers' use of artificial intelligence, with clear direction on one of the most practical questions firms face: how to bill when AI does part of the work.
The Legal Ethics Guidelines for Lawyers' Use of Artificial Intelligence, prepared by the Association's Committee on Artificial Intelligence and Emerging Technologies, were adopted by its House of Delegates on 31 October 2026.
Key points
- Billing: Lawyers who bill by the hour may charge only for time actually spent, including time spent instructing an AI tool and reviewing, verifying or revising its output. They should not bill for hours the tool saved, or for time spent learning to use it.
- Costs: General AI subscriptions are treated as firm overhead unless the cost is specific to a matter and disclosed to the client.
- Verification: Material AI output should be checked before it is relied on or sent to a client or court.
- Confidentiality and supervision: The guidelines also cover protecting client information, telling clients about AI use, and supervising AI tools and vendors.
The guidelines do not amend New York's Rules of Professional Conduct. They are the bar's interpretation of how existing duties, especially the rule on reasonable fees, apply to AI. Their adoption comes as AI use in the profession grows quickly: the American Bar Association reports that 69% of legal professionals used some form of AI in 2026, up from 31% in 2025.
The takeaway for Nigerian practice: As more Nigerian firms adopt AI tools, the same questions about fair fees, client consent and verification will arise under the Rules of Professional Conduct and the Legal Practitioners' Remuneration Order.
Sources: FindLaw, New York State Bar Association.
Was this story helpful?


Responses (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.